Web
Analytics

The Best Resource For Mixed Martial Arts MMA

PAC executive director discusses controversial Ashlee Evans-Smith vs. Marion Reneau decision

236 0

PITTSBURGH — UFC Fight Night 83 brought a main card full of action and quick finishes to FOX Sports 1, but the evening did not kick off so smoothly in Pittsburgh.

Early on the card, during the Fight Pass early prelims, Ashlee Evans-Smith and Marion Reneau fought to a decision, with the vast majority of media members scoring either a draw or a victory for Reneau. In the first round, Reneau rocked Evans-Smith with punches at the outset and then almost finished the bout with a guillotine just as the bell sounded.

That didn’t stop two judges, Phil Rogers and Andrew Adkins, for scoring the round inexplicably for Evans-Smith.

Pennsylvania Athletic Commission executive director Greg Sirb talked about this decision after the event.

“There wasn’t any controversy,” Sirb told MMA Fighting. “Reneau wins the first round. … The second round was up for grabs, and then the third round [Evans-Smith] won. So it came down to who won that second round. That’s what it came down to.”

The problem with this reasoning is that two judges scored the first for Evans-Smith despite Reneau’s dominance. Sirb said the judges were fully aware of which fighter was which, and they submitted the score for what they believe transpired inside the Octagon.

“Everybody knew [who was who],” Sirb said. “We talked about it [the decision], and it was straight-up. They said she [Evans-Smith] won most of the [first] round, and Reneau came on strong. [Reneau] threw a flurry, but she [Evans-Smith] blocked everything and then Reneau had her in some type of choke, probably 10 seconds left.”

All but one media member or outlet had Reneau winning the fight, according to MMADecisions.com. Two media members had Reneau winning the first round 10-8. Yet, Rogers and Adkins cageside had Evans-Smith winning the five minutes. ….View full article

Source:: mma fighting